To track Reddit leads, use a simple pipeline with six stages: found, qualified, replied, engaged, converted, closed. For each thread, record the link, the person's need, your reply, and a follow-up date. Without a pipeline, good conversations get forgotten after one reply.
The six stages
| Stage | Meaning | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Found | Thread matches your keywords | Read and decide |
| Qualified | Real, recent need you can help with | Draft a helpful reply |
| Replied | You answered in the thread | Set a check-back date |
| Engaged | They replied, asked more or visited | Continue helping; offer a resource |
| Converted | Signed up, booked a call or bought | Hand off to sales or onboarding |
| Closed | No fit or no response | Archive with a reason |

Fields to keep
- Thread URL and subreddit.
- Need in one sentence.
- Intent level (low, medium, high) or a score.
- Your reply (or a link to it).
- Tags, such as competitor mentioned or feature requested.
- Next follow-up date.
Option 1: Spreadsheet
Free and flexible: one row per thread, a column for each field, and filters by stage and date. Works well up to a few dozen leads a month.
Option 2: A lead inbox built for Reddit
TrolyReddit keeps the source thread together with your notes, tags, follow-up dates and six-stage status, inside your browser. You can filter items due for follow-up and export your data. Selected leads can be synced in a batch to a TrolyPage workspace, with a receipt and visible revisions if edits conflict.
Weekly review checklist
- Follow up on all items due this week.
- Move stale "Replied" items to Closed after 2 weeks with no activity.
- Note common needs and share them with the product and content teams.
- Count conversions and the subreddits they came from.
FAQ
Should I DM leads?
Only if they invite it. Keep the conversation in public threads otherwise.
How do I attribute sign-ups to Reddit?
Use UTM links where links are allowed, and add a "how did you hear about us?" question at sign-up.
Written by the TrolyPage team. Updated November 2026.