The situation
You help moderate a hobby community with two volunteer shifts. A reported post may arrive just before one moderator signs off, so the next person needs to know what is unresolved without guessing. The example below is fictional. Set your own community rules and urgency targets; the times here are team conventions, not Reddit requirements.
Reddit explains that communities have their own rules and moderators can remove content from a community feed but cannot delete another user’s post from Reddit. The moderation log helps a team review recorded actions; it does not replace a handoff for work still awaiting a decision.
Copy this filled shift table
| Case | Evidence and rule | Action so far | Next owner and checkpoint |
|---|---|---|---|
| Report A: duplicate product question | Link to post; possible repetitive-post rule | None; verify whether weekly thread covers it | Sam: review before 18:00; apply rule consistently |
| Report B: suspected spam | Link and relevant rule; no speculation about identity | Removed from community; reason recorded | Lee: review any appeal at next shift |
| Report C: imminent safety concern | Link and brief factual description | Escalated through platform reporting channels | Lead moderator: check promptly; do not investigate privately |
Keep the actual table in a restricted team location. Record the minimum needed, link to the material rather than copying private information, and agree on retention with your team.
Use the template during each shift
- Review reports in context, including the actual community rule and relevant Reddit-wide rules. Separate observable facts from guesses.
- Record whether the case is awaiting review, actioned, appealed or escalated. Add the next owner and a realistic checkpoint.
- Before acting, check the moderation log to avoid duplicate or conflicting actions. When appropriate, explain the relevant rule in a respectful removal reason.
- At shift change, the incoming moderator acknowledges open cases and flags anything they cannot handle. Review a sample of decisions weekly for consistency.
Important exception: urgent safety
Do not let an urgent threat wait for the next scheduled shift. Use Reddit’s reporting tools and the team’s emergency procedure promptly. Avoid promising confidentiality or attempting to identify or contact a person outside approved procedures.
Check whether the handoff works
For a one-week trial, count open cases without an owner, cases past their team-set checkpoint, and reversals caused by missing context. Discuss a few anonymized examples at the end of the week. A falling backlog alone does not prove better moderation: inspect whether decisions are fair and appeals receive attention.